A Guide to Wyckoff’s Best Restaurants

A Guide to Wyckoff’s Best Restaurants

  • Maryanne Elsaesser
  • 01/14/22

Although it is a small town in Bergen County, Wyckoff is full of exceptional restaurants. This charming New Jersey township boasts eateries with stellar food and drinks, stylish venues, and exemplary service. 

Whether you’re searching for elevated brunch, Asian food, or farm-to-table cuisine, here’s a guide to Wyckoff’s absolute best restaurants.

Willow & Whisk

Credit: Willow & Whisk

Looking for elevated breakfast and lunch in Wyckoff? Check out the superb Willow & Whisk! This brunch eatery was named “Best Breakfast,” “Best Brunch” and “Best New Restaurant in 2021” by 201 Magazine.

The team at Willow & Whisk puts care and passion into every dish they create by using only the finest ingredients. The restaurant takes breakfast and lunch classics to a whole new level, providing diners with an outstanding culinary experience.

Some top breakfast picks include mini buttermilk pancakes, frittata bites, brioche french toast, and avocado toast. Another interesting choice is their shakshuka plate, which is Mediterranean poached eggs cooked in tomato sauce with peppers, onions, and feta cheese.

For lunch, try the crispy brussels sprouts, poached kale Caesar salad, chicken Caprese sandwich, or Manchego chicken sandwich. The Goddess Chicken is a standout dish — it’s got grilled chicken topped with avocado, lettuce, pickled red onion, and green goddess dressing served on a toasted brioche bun. 

Don’t forget to get one of their housemade beverages too! Willow & Whisk serves a variety of specialty coffees like nitro cold brew, an oat and honey latte, and espresso topped with cream. Their freshly squeezed juices are also a hit.

Willow & Whisk is the hottest spot for brunch in Wyckoff.

Credit: The Brick House

The Brick House

The Brick House is a premier Wyckoff restaurant with exceptional food and drink in a timeless setting. 

This lavish steakhouse has been in business for over 50 years and is located in a historic Federal Greek Revival farmhouse. The Brick House is a landmark dining destination not just in Wyckoff, but in the entire state of New Jersey, too.

Dining at The Brick House certainly lives up to the hype. The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner and offers a special Sunday Family Menu. All of the steaks at The Brick House are certified Black Angus, while the fish is brought in daily from The New Fulton Fish Market. House specialties for two include a rack of lamb cooked in garlic and rosemary and a flavorful fish stew. 

All-time favorite steaks include the tender New York strip and juicy filet mignon, both of which are served with a house salad and either a baked potato, french fries, or rice.

All of the restaurant’s dining rooms are gorgeously designed and decorated. These banquets can be reserved for private events, too. Plus, The Brick House touts a chic Main Bar, Wine Room, and Cigar Bar. Each of these bars has a club-like feel complete with large TVs and fireplaces. The service at this refined steakhouse is impeccable, too. The staff’s hospitality and professionalism are unlike any other. 

The Brick House is an elegant restaurant perfect for any special occasion.

Wyckoff Thai

Credit: Wyckoff Thai

For authentic Thai food, check out Wyckoff Thai!

This delicious restaurant has all the Thai specialties you could want. Start your meal with some spring rolls, steamed dumplings, or crab rangoon. Their Tom Yum Soup is a famous dish known for its distinct flavor and detoxifying properties. The soup is spiced with lemongrass, lime, chili, cilantro, and scallions, giving it a fiery yet tangy flavor. For entrees, popular dishes include pineapple fried rice, pad Thai, basil chicken, and Thai coconut curry.

If you’re in the mood for a treat, Wyckoff Thai has some tasty, unique desserts. The sweet sticky rice with mango is a tropical delight, while the fried banana with ice cream is the perfect balance of hot and cold. Thai food can pack quite a punch when it comes to spice, so ordering a soothing Thai ice tea is always a great choice, too.

Wyckoff Thai is a local gem serving scrumptious Thai delicacies to the community. 

The Barn Original

Credit: The Barn Original

The Barn Original is all about excellent food, drinks, and good times with friends and family. 

Formerly a dairy barn and speakeasy, this burger and barbecue restaurant is a Wyckoff staple. The bar at The Barn was originally crafted from a farm wagon, which still stands today, wheels and all. It has also become a tradition for people to carve their names or initials into the restaurant’s wooden tables while waiting to be served. 

For your appetizer, order the deep-fried zucchini sticks, spicy buffalo wings, or grilled portobello mushrooms on top of greens. The Barn Burger is a favorite main dish complete with bacon, cheddar cheese, sauteed onions, and a zesty barbecue sauce. You can’t go wrong with any of their burgers though. The saucy barbecue baby back ribs are also mouthwatering and served with large onion rings and your choice of potato.

Don’t forget to order a drink at The Barn’s cool Western bar. Apart from a nice selection of beer and wine, The Barn crafts specialty cocktails. These housemade libations change seasonally and feature both classic and quirky concoctions. 

The Barn Original is a noteworthy place to create memories while savoring some wonderful food and drinks.

Sakura Japanese Restaurant

Credit: Uber Eats

For traditional Japanese fare, dine at Sakura Japanese Restaurant!

This Japanese eatery makes a variety of creative sushi and sashimi rolls. Their Sushi Boat is a house favorite and includes an assortment of rolls alongside soup and salad. The Sushi Boat is meant for sharing — it can contain anywhere from 10 up to 42 pieces. A range of fish and meats can be used for Sakura’s golden fried tempura and savory teriyaki dishes. Sakura’s bento boxes are also one of the most popular items on the menu. These boxes contain tempura, soup, salad, dumplings, rice, and a choice of California or tuna roll. Sakura’s udon and soba noodles are two other fantastic choices and include your choice of protein.

Japanese beverages are available at Sakura as well. A Japanese soda or juice is a perfect accompaniment to Sakura’s tasty dishes. Their green tea is also a must — it’s brought out in a beautiful Japanese tea kettle. 

Much like you would experience in Japan, the atmosphere in Sakura is trendy and classy. Ambient lighting and wood accents add to the vibe, as do Japanese figurines. A glass sushi bar displays fresh sashimi. 

Sakura Japanese Restaurant is by far Wyckoff’s best Japanese eatery.

Cafe Amici

Credit: Cafe Amici

Looking for amazing farm-to-table cuisine? Stop by the delectable Cafe Amici! From fresh fish and meats to artisan pizza and pasta, this high-quality restaurant sources its ingredients from the finest local farmers and purveyors. 

Cafe Amici offers a seasonal menu inspired by the flavors of Italy. All pasta sauces are made to order daily, while the pizza flour is imported straight from Naples, Italy. The produce is organic and the fish and meats are raised hormone-free and wild-caught.

Must-try dishes at Cafe Amici include the penne in vodka sauce, rigatoni in bolognese sauce, chicken parmesan, mushroom pizza, and arugula and goat cheese pizza. Cafe Amici is also a BYOB establishment, so remember to bring your preferred alcoholic beverages if you’d like.

Make sure to save room for dessert! Cafe Amici’s gelato was named “Best of Bergen County 2011” by Bergen Health & Life Magazine. Enjoy light and creamy flavors like hazelnut, strawberry, pistachio, and stracciatella. The restaurant has heavenly cannolis and tiramisu too. 

Cafe Amici whips up standout Italian-inspired cuisine in a sustainable and environmentally conscious way.

Wyckoff real estate

Discover the most luxurious properties in Wyckoff, New Jersey by contacting real estate agent Maryanne Elsaesser. A longtime resident of Wyckoff, Maryanne’s tenacity and focus make her a brilliant negotiator. To secure the best homes for sale in Wyckoff, trust Maryanne Elsaesser. 



Work With Us

We love what we do, and the greatest reward is feedback from clients expressing their gratitude about their experience while we were either selling their home, helping them purchase a new property or both. We want only success for our clients.

Follow Us On Instagram